Skip to content

What losing at squash taught me about cutting losses

The question

"You come across as very calm about losing money. Were you always like that?"

Asked by Tom, Auckland
Ray Whitlock in squash whites, lunging into a forehand on a white court, the city skyline through the glass wall behind him

Tom, no. I was terrible at it. What fixed me was a 26-year-old analyst named Kenji and a squash court at six in the morning.

Every Tuesday for three years, Kenji has beaten me most weeks. He’s younger, faster, and he doesn’t get tired. I’ve got thirty years of experience and a bad knee. You can guess how that goes.

The game I used to play

When I started losing to him, I did what everyone does. I went 2-0 down and tried harder at the thing that wasn’t working. Hit it harder. Run faster. Chase every ball. I was trying to win back the points I’d lost, and I was losing more of them doing it.

That’s exactly how people treat a share that’s fallen. They bought at $10, it’s at $6, and they won’t sell until it’s “back to even”. Some buy more, so they can “average down”. Sometimes that works out. Often it’s just doing more of what wasn’t working, with more money.

Why we do it

The court doesn’t care how many points you’ve lost. Neither does the market.

Psychologists call it loss aversion: losing $100 feels worse than winning $100 feels good. So we’ll take risks to avoid locking in a loss that we’d never take to make a gain. That’s how a small loss becomes a big one.

The fix isn’t “always sell your losers”. Sometimes a share falls because the market is being silly, and the patient owner wins. The fix is to stop making the decision based on what you paid. The price you paid is a sunk cost. The court doesn’t remember it. Neither does the market.

What changed my game

About a year in, I stopped trying to win back points and started asking a different question between games: “Knowing what I know now, what’s my best play from here?”

Against Kenji, the answer was to stop running and start lobbing. Slow the game down, hit the back corners, make him do the work. I still lose most weeks. But I win more than I used to, and the losses are closer.

With investments, the same question works. Forget what you paid. If you had the cash instead of the shares today, would you buy them at this price? If yes, hold. If no, you have your answer, even if it stings.

The rule I’d give my younger self

Before you go into a position, or a match, write down what would make you change your mind. “If the company loses its biggest customer, I’m out.” “If I’m down 2-0, switch to lobs.” Then, when it happens, you’re following a decision you made with a clear head, not making a new one with a racing pulse.

Kenji won 3-1 this morning. I’ll be back next Tuesday.

Ray

▶60-second video answer coming soon
Share on X Ask your own question →

Ray Whitlock is a fictional AI character. Everything here is general information and entertainment, not financial, legal or tax advice. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on anything, consider whether it's right for you and speak to a licensed professional.