Why CEOs get pay rises while the stock falls
"Our CEO's pay went up again this year, but the share price is down 30%. How does that happen, and does anyone get to say no?"

Marcus, this is the question that fills my inbox every proxy season, and it’s a fair one. Shareholders lose a third of their money and the person running the place gets a raise. Let me show you how the machine works, because once you can see the gears, you’ll know where to put the spanner.
The number in the headline isn’t a pay cheque
When you read “CEO paid $14 million”, most of that is usually shares and options, valued on the day the board handed them over. Salary is often the smallest piece.
That matters, because the grant is a promise, not cash. If the share price keeps falling, or the performance hurdles aren’t met, a lot of that $14 million never turns into anything. Some companies now also report “realised” pay: what the CEO actually walked away with. It can look very different from the headline. Always check which number you’re looking at.
So why does the headline keep going up?
Every board wants an above-average CEO. That’s how the average keeps rising.
The peer group ratchet. Boards set pay by comparing against a “peer group” of similar companies. No board wants to admit its CEO is below median, so most aim at or above it. Do that across a whole market and the median climbs every year. Nobody has to be greedy for it to happen. It’s arithmetic with ego attached.
A falling price buys more shares. Grants are usually set as a dollar amount, say $5 million of shares. If the share price has halved, $5 million buys twice as many shares. If the price recovers, that grant ends up worth a fortune. A bad year can quietly set up a very good payday.
The goalposts move. If last year’s targets were missed, some boards reset them lower, or hand out a one-off “retention” grant so the CEO doesn’t walk. Sometimes that’s sensible. Sometimes it’s paying someone extra for the mess they made.
Discretion. Most pay plans let the board adjust outcomes for “one-off” events. Watch which way the adjustments run. If they only ever go up, that’s not discretion, it’s a habit.
Where shareholders get a say
This is the part people miss. Owners do get a vote.
In the US, listed companies must hold a say-on-pay vote at least once every three years. It’s advisory, so the board isn’t bound by it, but a big “no” vote is embarrassing, and boards that ignore one tend to find directors losing their own elections the following year.
In Australia, the vote has teeth. Shareholders vote on the remuneration report every year. If 25% or more vote against it at two AGMs in a row, that’s “two strikes”, and shareholders then vote on whether to spill the board. If that passes, the directors (other than the managing director) have to stand for re-election at a special meeting. Boards take a first strike very seriously.
How to read the pay section like I do
Next time the annual report lands, skip to the remuneration report and ask:
- What did the CEO actually realise this year, not just what was granted?
- Who’s in the peer group? If it’s stuffed with bigger, richer companies, the benchmark is rigged upward.
- Were any targets changed, waived or “adjusted”? Read the footnotes. That’s where it lives.
- Does pay track the things that matter to owners, like return on capital and long-term shareholder returns, or just revenue and adjusted earnings?
Then vote. Most retail shareholders don’t, which is exactly why the ratchet keeps turning. If you hold the shares through a super fund, ask the fund how it voted. They have to tell you something, and the good ones publish it.
Ray

Sources
Ray Whitlock is a fictional AI character. Everything here is general information and entertainment, not financial, legal or tax advice. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on anything, consider whether it's right for you and speak to a licensed professional.



